Chef Casey Thompson
Folktable, Sonoma
Let’s get it over with and say Chef Casey Thompson was on “Top Chef.” And she did damn well, making it to the finals of the popular TV show’s Season Three in Miami, and being voted fan favorite. And let’s follow up quickly to say that was 14 years ago—and a lot has happened since (including more appearances on “Top Chef “).
Casey is currently the consulting executive chef at Sonoma’s Folktable, and culinary director of Sonoma’s Best Hospitality Group, the owner of Folktable. “The restaurant is a really vibrant place to gather. We have beautiful, seasonal food, live music, pop-ups. People gather with their friends to share an incredible cheese board or a meal,” she excitedly said before my visit.
Over the past couple of years, Sonoma’s Best Hospitality Group has purchased several landmark Sonoma sites, including the General’s Daughter, for which they say they have big plans, and the Sonoma Cheese Factory, which recently re-opened. “Having a supportive team behind me is so important,” Casey said. “Not having the same core restaurant values as the owners has been the downfall of a few [of my] past projects, so I really appreciate where I am now.”
Casey has been in California for 13 years, but she will always remain a Texan. “I dropped my accent because I didn’t want to sound like a hick, but after a few drinks, my partner says, ‘Here comes Texas.’” Born and raised in Dallas, Casey says her paternal family is “straight Texas,” and her maternal side is French, I mean, Parisian. This cultural coupling, etched most sharply by her grandmothers, is a culinary origin story.
On one side is Casey’s Texan grandmother, kneading out biscuits for drop-in guests, and on the other, her French grandmother lecturing her on the proper way to make mayonnaise (and you had better use a wooden spoon).
After graduating from the University of North Texas with a degree in marketing, Casey took a job selling jet fuel at a private airport in Houston. “I got to wear a cute suit, do work I liked and go home at 5pm.” When she wasn’t working, though, she developed a habit of copying recipes by hand from cookbooks, newspapers and magazines. “I have boxes and boxes of them,” she says of her self-described Rain Man phase.
When Casey finally summoned the nerve to ask her mother for money to go to culinary school, “she said no,” recalls the chef. Having already paid for college, her mother suggested she work in “the bowels of a kitchen” and see if she really liked it before shelling out tens of thousands of dollars for cooking school.
A couple of Casey’s qualities come through as soon as you meet her. One is her charm. The other is her determination. Once she locked into the idea of getting a cooking gig, she moved to Dallas, put on her jet-fuel-selling suit and marched straight into the legendary Mansion on Turtle Creek. The human resources liaison looked over her restaurant-less resume and took her to the sous chef, who walked her straight to legendary chef Dean Fearing’s kitchen office.
“Cooks love to torture you. But I told him I could do it and he told me to come back Monday morning at 5am.” That was the start of five years at the Mansion, where she began as an anchor to her prep colleagues, and ended with the title of sous chef. “Nowadays it is harder to get a chance to be a burden in a kitchen and learn that way,” she said.
She was clearly a quick study, because Fearing tapped Casey to helm the new restaurant that his (now ex-) wife, Lynae Fearing and Chef Ken Rathbun’s wife, Tracy Rathbun, were opening. Today, Shinsei is still a popular spot in Dallas, and still serving some of Casey’s dishes (try her take on fried rice if you visit). “They wanted to create this cool pan-Asian restaurant with an open-concept sushi bar and they wanted me as the executive chef. That was my first … everything. Such big trust.”
The good press and reservations were immediate. From management, to making pastry, to tweaking the menu, Casey was hands-on and head-down. “I did everything.” And then the phone rang. And rang. And rang.
The “Top Chef “casting agents were “stalking pretty hard. But it felt like I couldn’t leave the restaurant.” After hearing that a local friend/rival was in the running, the prospect got more enticing and Casey agreed to a meeting. It was an offer she couldn’t refuse.
In the show’s early seasons, contestants had to completely sequester for months. “You just disappeared and then dropped out of the sky [on television] one day.”
“When I came back [to Shinsei], it was crazy. We were not prepared for what was coming. I was getting pulled in 17 different directions, companies were calling, wanting to promote us. I really wanted to focus on the restaurant. It was just getting impossible.”
It was getting hard for the restaurant, as well. “It was a real adult conversation. They were, like, ‘We need you here.’ And I was, like, ‘I can’t be here.’ And they were, like, ‘OK, then.’”
Casey moved on to explore the other opportunities created from her exposure on television. A gig for Clorox, which has food brands under its corporate umbrella, brought her to the Bay Area. “As a Texas girl, I wanted to get in a bigger pond and grow. And, also, there was a guy here that I was interested in. Still with that guy today.”
She moved to Yerba Buena Island, which “was nuts. I would wake up and my sheets were soaked because I left the window open. And then the ships would go through and blow their horns and knock me out of bed.” She spent a few years cooking for wineries. She opened anothwer restaurant in Texas, playing with upscale Southern classics.
Then she got her opening to swim in the San Francisco restaurant scene, at the Warwick Hotel. Named Aveline— the French version of her Southern grandmother’s name, Hazel—the restaurant was an homage to Casey’s culinary forebears. “I had some really, really amazing people on my team. And we did lots of tricked out food. I thought we were doing something cool in San Francisco.”
On a busy night, former SF Chronicle restaurant critic Michael Bauer came in. “I’ll never forget the review, it said ‘Casey Thompson may be a great chef. But Aveline is not where she shines.’ So that was that.” On top of her disappointment about the review, the ownership wasn’t a good match and Casey decided to leave. “I came home. I think I slept for a week. It was like a death.”
There were a few other dots on her timeline, but suffice to say Chef Casey Thompson is feeling at home now. She and her partner, winemaker Michael DeSantis, live in the town of Sonoma. They are regulars at the local spots, they’ve fallen in love with the Tuesday night Valley of the Moon Farmers’ Market, they work hard, but they still have time for each other.
“On ‘Top Chef,’ you have to understand what your style is. I still struggle with that. When I went back for the all-star season 14, I’d seen a lot of those chefs searching for their voice. But they found themselves somewhere in these years. I just kept going back to that clean California style of letting things be what they are. You can’t always cook that way, everywhere, unless you really get great ingredients.”
“At Folktable, if we make a croque madame, then every ingredient is going to be kick ass. We’re going to make tater tots, a burger, a cheeseboard, but we are going to make them extraordinary.”
“What I am is from Texas. So, I can lose the accent, but the South is still there. My grandmother made us feel so welcome and loved when we would sit around the table and she would make biscuits for whoever showed up. That’s what I want people to feel, coming to my restaurant.”
Edible Marin & Wine Country: What was the first meal you made that you were proud of?
CHEF CASEY THOMPSON: I made a Spanish flan when I was 14, following a recipe. I even made the caramel sauce! Thinking about that now, that was a really big deal.
EMWC: What was your favorite food as a kid?
There was a place called Joe’s Seafood just outside of Dallas, where I grew up. We’d stop there every weekend on the way to our lake house. I LOVED the fried oysters, catfish and crab claw gumbo. I still love fried seafood. So moist and crispy, with lemon and tartar sauce.
EMWC: What food do you wish you loved?
This does not compute.
EMWC: What food do you love unreasonably much?
That’s too easy. Ask any friend of mine: Cheetos.
EMWC: What is the most difficult cooking technique to do well?
Making a really good, consistent omelet.
EMWC: What are you exploring in your kitchen now?
I’ve got the vegan/vegetarian bug. I want to reduce our dependency on meat. The problem is that many of our brains are wired to depend on meat to make a meal.
EMWC: What non-culinary influences inspire you?
Winemaking. Farming. Conservation.
EMWC: What is your idea of a very healthy meal?
Brunch, but more of a French brunch. Eggs, salad, “cold cuts,” as my grandmother would say, and fruit. A bit of wine (for health purposes only).
EMWC: What is your favorite ingredient?
Herbs. They make the world go ‘round. Any and all of them. Or mayonnaise. Or butter. This is a tough one.
EMWC: What is your favorite hangover meal?
Also easy: cheeseburger and fries with a side of nap
EMWC: What restaurant in the world are you most dying to try?
Frantzen in Stockholm, Sweden.
EMWC: What kitchen utensil is most indispensable to you?
My spoons. They really are everything. Basting. Turning. Plating.
They truly do what we wish we could just do with our fingers.
EMWC: Who do you most like to cook for?
My man and my friends. I love how much they look forward to it. We get together over some of the best meals and laugh. It’s good for the soul.
EMWC: If you could do one other job, what would it be?
Esthetician. I love all the little jars, tinctures, dimly lit rooms, spa music and the way they make people feel.
EMWC: What is your favorite midnight snack?
Gummy bears. Haribo, old school.
EMWC: What most satisfies your sweet tooth?
Ditto on the gummy bears.
EMWC: What would you eat at your last meal, if you could plan such a thing? Kinmedai sushi with Yuzu Kosho at Morimoto Napa from Yuichiro Tsuji.
Oysters and Pearls from the French Laundry in Yountville, Focaccia from Silvia Barban at LaRina in Brooklyn, NY, Cabeza Taquiquesos from a street cart in Guadalajara, Duck carnitas from Cosme in New York City, A warm apple fritter from Roth’s Grocery Store in Silverton, OR.
EMWC: What’s your favorite place to go for (and what is your favorite thing to order) for …
… a splurge meal? We have been going to Morimoto in Napa for over 10 years. We sit at the sushi bar in front of our friend Yuichiro Tsuji and do NOT hold back. He pulls out all of the stops. Also, Angler in SF for caviar.
… breakfast? Malasadas from Leonard’s in Oahu, HI
… pastry? Canele from The Wayward Baker, Mimi Mendoza at Senia in Honolulu, HI
… a late-night/after-work meal? Korean chicken wings at COCO BANG, San Francisco
… a cup of coffee? Still searching
… a greasy-spoon meal? Norma’s Cafe, Oak Cliff, TX
… groceries? Farmers’ market or Sonoma Market
… ice cream? Sweet Scoops in Sonoma! Watmaugh Strawberry flavor! I just discovered it during the pandemic and love it.
… chocolate? You’ve got the wrong girl.
And lastly but not leastly … what is your favorite local wine or beer for the season? Harumph Chardonnay from Glen Ellen (my man, Michael DeSantis, makes it). And I love Grenache (my summer red).